How to Tell Your Partner Your Fantasies (Without Shame or Awkwardness)

The JournalNo. 048 min read
How to Tell Your Partner Your Fantasies (Without Shame or Awkwardness)
I have fantasies I want to explore.
You've typed that sentence into the notes on your phone more than once and deleted it every time.
Tonight it's late on a Sunday. He's lying beside you in the dark with one warm arm draped across your waist, his thumb drawing lazy circles on your hip, and the sentence is sitting right behind your teeth.
If I say it out loud, will he look at me differently?
Here's what I'd tell you over a glass of wine: you share a fantasy slowly and warmly, starting with the feeling it gives you rather than every detail of the script. Almost everyone has fantasies they've never shared, and telling your partner one is an invitation into closeness, never a complaint about your sex life.
No. 01
Is it normal to have sexual fantasies you've never told your partner?
The short answer
Yes.
Sexual fantasies are nearly universal, and most people carry at least one they have never said out loud. Keeping a fantasy private doesn't mean anything is wrong with you or with your relationship. It usually means the desire feels tender and you want to protect it.
In a survey of 4,175 Americans for his book Tell Me What You Want, Kinsey Institute researcher Justin Lehmiller found that 96 percent of women and 93 percent of men had fantasized about BDSM themes like power and bondage.
And men, that fantasy you've kept to yourself since your twenties is more ordinary than you think.
He shifts beside you and nuzzles into your neck. "You're thinking so loud I can hear it," he murmurs. "What's going on in there?"
↑ Back to the guideNo. 02
Does having a fantasy mean I want to act it out?
The short answer
No.
A fantasy can be thrilling precisely because it stays imaginary. Some fantasies you might love to try in a safe, adapted form, and others are meant to live only in your mind. Wanting something in fantasy is never a promise to do it.
Hold your fantasy lightly when you share it. You're telling him something that turns you on, the way you'd tell him about a dream you had.
↑ Back to the guideNo. 03
What is my fantasy really telling me?
The short answer
Your fantasy is pointing toward a feeling you crave. Underneath the specific scenario there is usually a longing for something like intensity, attention, pursuit, surrender, novelty, worship or permission. Understanding that feeling is often more powerful than recreating the exact scene.
"Can I tell you something I've been thinking about?" you whisper, trailing your fingertips slowly down his chest.
"Always," he murmurs, pulling you closer.
You take a breath. "Sometimes I imagine you pinning me down and telling me exactly what to do."
Immediately, his breath changes and his hand tightens on your hip. "God, that's hot," he says, his voice dropping low. "Tell me more."
Before you say it, ask yourself what you feel inside the fantasy. Maybe it's the relief of not having to decide anything after a week of deciding everything. Maybe it's the thrill of being wanted so badly that he can't keep his hands off you. Once you know the feeling, you have a direction, and there are a hundred delicious ways to get there.
↑ Back to the guideNo. 04
How do I tell my partner my fantasy without it being awkward?
The short answer
Choose a relaxed moment outside of sex, like lying close in bed or a long walk, and share the feeling before the details. Something like, "I love being with you, and there's something I've been curious about," lets your partner lean in with curiosity rather than defensiveness.
If you want words, try these: "I feel so close to you, and I want to share something that turns me on. It's a little vulnerable for me, so would you just listen first?" That last line tells him exactly how to hold what you're giving him.
↑ Back to the guideNo. 05
What if my partner judges me?
The short answer
If your partner reacts with surprise or discomfort, give it time before deciding it means judgment. First reactions are often about nerves. Ask what came up for them, listen without defending yourself and remember that your desire is valid whether or not they want to share it.
"Really?" he says, and you can hear the delighted surprise in his voice. "I've thought about that so many times. I just never knew if you'd want it. I didn't want you to think I was too much."
He's been wanting this too, you think, and you grin into the dark.
A partner won't always respond this warmly right away, and a first reaction of surprise is usually nerves. If yours goes quiet or looks uncomfortable, try: "I can see this surprised you. I'm not asking you to do anything. I just wanted you to know me." Then give it a day.
↑ Back to the guideNo. 06
What if my partner thinks I'm unhappy with our sex life?
The short answer
Say it directly. Let them know that sharing a fantasy is about wanting more closeness and play with them, and that it isn't a criticism of what you already share. Reassurance at the very beginning prevents most of the hurt that can come from this conversation.
So say it plainly: "I love our sex life. I just want to explore even more of each other."
"So you're not bored of me?" he teases, but you can hear how much he needed to ask.
You roll on top of him and kiss him. "I'm the opposite of bored."
↑ Back to the guideNo. 08
What if one of us is interested and the other isn't?
The short answer
That's normal, and it doesn't have to end the conversation. Look for the feeling underneath the fantasy and find a version you're both genuinely excited about. Nobody should be pressured into something they don't want, and nobody should be shamed for wanting it.
There is usually plenty of room between a yes and a no. Maybe he doesn't want to role-play a stranger, but he'd love to take charge of a whole evening. Maybe you don't want anything rough, but you'd love to be held still and teased.
↑ Back to the guideNo. 09
How do we explore the feeling of a fantasy without acting it out literally?
The short answer
Translate the fantasy into its core feeling, then design a small, safe experience around that feeling. If the fantasy is about surrender, it might become one evening where your partner leads every decision. The emotional truth of a fantasy can be satisfied in countless gentle ways.
"So what would a little taste of it look like?" he asks, his hand drifting slowly down your spine.
"Maybe you just hold my wrists and tell me what to do," you say. "And I'm not allowed to help."
"I think I can manage that," he says, and you can feel him smiling against your shoulder.
You keep the feeling and adapt the form, so a fantasy of being taken over becomes his hand pinning your wrists gently to the pillow while you both know your safe word changes everything.
↑ Back to the guideNo. 10
What's a safe first experiment?
The short answer
Choose something short and easy to stop, and agree in advance on what's off-limits. Pick a safe word, which is a word either of you can use to pause or stop at any moment. Afterward, talk about what you both liked and what you'd want next time, because that conversation builds trust for everything that follows.
The next night, he doesn't wait for you to bring it up. Immediately after he turns off the lamp, he takes both of your wrists in one hand and presses them into the pillow above your head.
"Your safe word?" he asks, and you tell him.
"Good," he says. "Now stay."
Afterward, tangled up in the sheets, he pulls you onto his chest. "Okay, tell me everything," he says. "What did you love? What would you change?" You tell him the wrists were perfect and you'd love more of his voice next time, and he admits that feeling you let go turned him on more than he expected.
Please don't skip this part. I always teach my clients that the conversation afterward is where you get the most information. You learn what each of you liked or didn't, and you discover what you're both up for next time. It's also where the trust grows, because each of you sees that honesty is safe and even sexy.
↑ Back to the guideIn closing
Your desire is a doorway
A fantasy is information about what you crave, and you never owe anyone a performance of it. When you share it with love, you're inviting your partner to know the most alive part of you.
The couples who feel closest still get shy. They just keep reaching for each other in the dark and saying, tell me more.
Source Justin J. Lehmiller, Tell Me What You Want (2018); see also Lehmiller, "The 7 Most Common Sex Fantasies," Sex and Psychology (2019), www.sexandpsychology.com/blog/2019/3/13/the-7-most-common-sex-fantasies-and-how-many-people-have-ever-had-them/, and Psychology Today's summary, www.psychologytoday.com/us/blog/all-about-sex/202107/the-7-most-popular-and-powerful-sexual-fantasies
Michelle XO
Ways to go deeper
Step one · Free · Sent to your inbox
Begin with the Yes, No, Maybe Checklist
If you're ready to start the conversation but don't know where to begin, let the list do the opening for you.
My free Yes, No, Maybe Checklist helps you and your partner discover what you're curious about privately, then compare answers in a way that feels playful instead of exposing.
Get the free Yes, No, Maybe Checklist →Ready to go deeper?
Step two · Online · Instant access
Seduce & Surrender
The Feminine Magnetism Bundle
If you have ever wanted to explore your submissive side in a way that feels deeply feminine and completely safe, this bundle was built for you.
The most irresistible thing a woman can be is both soft and powerful.
Four of my best-selling courses and masterclasses, on seduction, surrender, submission and feminine authority, brought together into one complete initiation.
This is not a course you take.This is a woman you become.
Seduction AcademyUnraveledThe Worshipped WomanUnapologetic Power
Total value $1,036$497Save $539
Client reflections
This work bought me back to my power, reminding me I’m a sexy goddess, divine queen who any man would love to worship.
Cori Hughes
For men: if you want to become the man she feels safe enough to tell everything, start with The Undeniable Man.
For men
This masterclass made it easy to go deeper and explore more fantasies and desires with my wife. So clear and easy to follow and also made me feel confident taking the lead.
MICHAEL G.
Frequently asked questions
Is it normal to fantasize about being dominated?
Yes. Fantasies about power and surrender are among the most common sexual fantasies. In Justin Lehmiller's survey of 4,175 Americans, 96 percent of women and 93 percent of men reported having had a fantasy involving BDSM themes such as bondage and dominance. Having this fantasy doesn't mean you want to be harmed or that anything is wrong with you.
What do women want in bed but won't ask for?
Many women want to feel truly desired and to be led with confidence and patience. They often don't ask because they fear seeming demanding or hurting their partner's feelings. Creating safety for her to speak, and responding with curiosity rather than defensiveness, makes these desires much easier to share.
How do I tell my partner I want to try something new in bed?
Choose a calm moment outside of sex and describe the feeling you're curious about, after telling them what you already love. Make it clear there's no pressure and that their honest response is welcome. Starting small and agreeing on a first experiment together makes trying something new feel safe and exciting.
Should I tell my partner all of my fantasies?
You don't have to share everything. Some fantasies are meant to stay private, and that's healthy. Share the ones you're genuinely curious to explore together or that would help your partner understand you more deeply. You can always start with the feeling behind a fantasy instead of the full details.
What if my partner's fantasy makes me uncomfortable?
Thank them for trusting you, then be honest about your feelings without shaming them. Ask what they love about the fantasy, since the underlying feeling may be something you'd enjoy in a different form. You never have to act out something that doesn't feel right, and your no deserves respect too.
Your next read
The answer to your next question…
No. 02Surrender
Why Powerful Women Crave Surrender (and Why It's Not Weakness)
if your fantasy is about being led, this explains why it's so common in strong women.
Read the article →
No. 05Desire & Kink
Kink for Beginners: How to Start Exploring (Sensually and Safely)
gentle first steps once you've started the conversation.
Read the article →
About the author
Hi, I’m Michelle Pound
“I don’t believe in suffering. I believe in seduction.”
Michelle Pound is an erotic liberator, intimacy guide and Shibari master who guides men, women and couples into conscious surrender and the hottest connection of their lives.
- Erotic Liberator
- Intimacy Guide
- Shibari Master
Stay connected with news and updates!
Join our mailing list to receive the latest news and updates from our team.
Don't worry, your information will not be shared.
We hate SPAM. We will never sell your information, for any reason.